Today on Dave Does History, we’re diving into the life, legacy, and legend of one of America’s most peculiar presidents—Grover Cleveland. You might not think much about the man who was both the 22nd and 24th president of the United States, but Cleveland was one of the most unique and controversial figures to ever occupy the White House. Born on this day in 1837, he was the first president to serve two nonconsecutive terms—booted out of office in 1888, only to claw his way back four years later. But his presidency was more than just an interesting footnote in history books.
This was a man who built his career on a reputation for integrity and reform—so much so that even some Republicans bolted their own party to vote for him. And yet, for all his talk of honesty, Cleveland found himself embroiled in a paternity scandal that led to one of the nastiest campaign slogans in history: “Ma, Ma, where’s my Pa?” (Don’t worry, his supporters got the last laugh: “Gone to the White House! Ha! Ha! Ha!”) But the drama didn’t stop there. He was a hard-nosed fiscal conservative who loved vetoing bills—so much that he struck down over 400 in his first term alone. He refused to hand out Civil War pensions to those he felt didn’t deserve them, opposed free silver (much to the fury of the agrarian wing of his own party), and used federal troops to break up the Pullman Strike in 1894, making him deeply unpopular with labor unions.
Despite his reputation for reform, Cleveland was also a man full of contradictions. He was a staunch opponent of government handouts, vetoing relief efforts during the Texas drought, yet he fiercely defended government regulation in areas like railroad oversight and tariff reform. He called himself a champion of the people but was happy to let the economy crumble during the Panic of 1893 without much intervention. He despised imperialism and refused to annex Hawaii, yet his administration aggressively policed domestic dissent. And let’s not forget his time as Sheriff of Erie County, New York, where he personally carried out two hangings—something no other president can claim on their résumé.
So today, we’ll break down the myths and realities of Grover Cleveland. Was he an honest reformer or just a stubborn political purist? A man of principle or a man out of his depth? And, perhaps most importantly—was the Baby Ruth candy bar really named after his daughter?
We’ll cover it all—his improbable rise, his bitter defeats, his contentious policies, and his lasting legacy. Plus, we’ll take your calls in the final segment to see how Cleveland’s brand of limited government stacks up against today’s political landscape.
Buckle up—it’s going to be a veto-filled ride.
Cleveland earned the nickname “The Veto Mayor” in Buffalo, where he took on political corruption and blocked wasteful spending. That reputation followed him to Albany, where he became Governor of New York and continued his war on corrupt machine politics. Tammany Hall, the Democratic Party’s powerhouse in New York, hated Cleveland with a passion—which, honestly, should be a pretty good sign that he was doing something right.
Then came the paternity scandal. During the 1884 presidential campaign, newspapers revealed that Cleveland may have fathered an illegitimate child years earlier. Unlike modern politicians who deny, deny, deny, Cleveland didn’t run from the accusation. He essentially said, Yeah, that might be my kid, took financial responsibility, and moved on. Voters appreciated his blunt honesty, and he won the 1884 election.
Cleveland’s first term was defined by reform, fiscal conservatism, and vetoing wasteful government spending. He fought against fraudulent Civil War pensions, refusing to give benefits to those who never actually fought. This made him wildly unpopular with Union veterans, a key voting bloc.
Then there was the tariff issue. Cleveland wanted lower tariffs, arguing that the government was hoarding too much taxpayer money. But Republicans twisted this into an attack on American industry, claiming Cleveland was weak on economic protectionism.
In 1888, Cleveland won the popular vote but lost the presidency thanks to Republican-led voter fraud and vote-buying in Indiana. Meanwhile, his own home state of New York flipped against him, thanks in part to his battles with Tammany Hall. Benjamin Harrison won the Electoral College, and Cleveland was out.
By 1892, Harrison was so unpopular that Cleveland staged a historic comeback. The economy was faltering, and the McKinley Tariff had driven up consumer prices. Cleveland ran on tariff reform, fiscal conservatism, and a return to normalcy. This time, he won both the popular vote and the Electoral College. It looked like a triumphant return—until everything fell apart.
The Panic of 1893 hit just two months into his second term, sending the economy into a tailspin. Banks collapsed, unemployment soared, and Cleveland’s hands-off approach made things even worse. Instead of stepping in, he stuck to the gold standard and refused to intervene, believing the market would fix itself.
Then came the Pullman Strike of 1894, when railroad workers walked off the job in protest of wage cuts. Cleveland sent federal troops to break the strike, leading to deadly clashes and turning organized labor against him forever.
By 1896, Cleveland was so politically toxic that his own party abandoned him. William Jennings Bryan and the free silver movement took over, and Cleveland didn’t even try to run again. He left office in 1897, more unpopular than ever.
Cleveland is the only president to leave office deeply unpopular TWICE. His honesty was both his greatest strength and his greatest weakness—he refused to bend, even when compromise might have saved him. His reforms, fiscal conservatism, and anti-imperialism left a lasting mark, but his refusal to help struggling Americans during the economic crisis cemented his fall from grace.
How do we view him today? Was he the last truly small-government Democrat? Or just too rigid for his own good? Would today’s Republicans or Democrats even claim him?
DAVE DOES HISTORY 
Leave a comment