No Victory, Not Even At Home

On March 17, 1973, a moment unfolded on the tarmac of Travis Air Force Base that would become one of the most iconic images of the Vietnam War era. Captured by Associated Press photographer Slava “Sal” Veder, the Pulitzer Prize-winning photograph known as Burst of Joy depicts what appears to be the pinnacle of a joyous reunion. Lt. Col. Robert L. Stirm, recently released from captivity as a prisoner of war in North Vietnam, strides across the tarmac as his family rushes toward him, arms outstretched in an expression of pure relief and elation. His fifteen-year-old daughter, Lorrie, is the most animated figure in the shot, her exuberance embodying what many Americans longed to believe about the homecomings of returning POWs. But as is so often the case with war, and with history itself, the truth behind the moment was far more complicated than it appeared.

Listen to the Article (approx 6:45)

To understand the depth of this image, one must first understand the war that preceded it and the arduous journey that led to Stirm’s return. By 1973, the Vietnam War had become one of the most controversial conflicts in American history. Opposition to U.S. involvement had grown steadily, with anti-war protests raging across the country, fueled by distrust of the government, the draft, and the staggering number of American casualties. The war had dragged on for years, and the American public, exhausted by the conflict, wanted an end to the fighting. After years of public unrest, diplomatic maneuvering, and heavy casualties, the United States had finally brokered an end to its involvement.

The Paris Peace Accords, signed on January 27, 1973, laid the groundwork for the withdrawal of American troops and the return of prisoners of war. The agreement was the result of lengthy negotiations led by key figures such as National Security Advisor Henry Kissinger and North Vietnamese diplomat Lê Đức Thọ. While both men were awarded the Nobel Peace Prize for their efforts, Thọ famously refused the honor, as the conflict in Vietnam was far from over despite the accords. The treaty stipulated that U.S. troops would leave Vietnam within sixty days, and North Vietnam agreed to return all American prisoners of war.

As part of the agreement, Operation Homecoming was launched, a mission to repatriate 591 American POWs held by North Vietnam and other factions. The operation began on February 12, 1973, with the first group of prisoners being flown to Clark Air Base in the Philippines for medical evaluations before being transported back to the United States. Among the hundreds of men waiting for their return home was Lt. Col. Robert L. Stirm.

Stirm’s story is one of resilience and hardship. A U.S. Air Force pilot, he was flying an F-105 Thunderchief over Hanoi when he was shot down on October 27, 1967. Captured by North Vietnamese forces, he endured more than five years of captivity in the infamous Hỏa Lò Prison—better known as the “Hanoi Hilton”—where he was subjected to the brutal treatment inflicted upon American prisoners. Interrogations, forced confessions, and physical abuse were routine, as the North Vietnamese sought to use POWs for propaganda purposes. Yet, like many of his fellow prisoners, Stirm endured through sheer willpower and the camaraderie of his fellow servicemen.

His long-awaited return home, however, came with an unexpected and devastating blow. Just three days before his arrival in the United States, he received a letter from his wife, Loretta. It was a Dear John letter, informing him that their marriage was over. During his years in captivity, Loretta had moved on, engaging in relationships with other men, and ultimately deciding to end their marriage. For Stirm, the emotional weight of this news would forever overshadow the moment that was captured on camera.

The moment itself, as seen through the lens of Slava Veder, remains a powerful image of reunion. The raw emotion on the faces of Stirm’s children, particularly Lorrie, conveys an undeniable sense of relief and love. Veder later recalled feeling the overwhelming energy in the air as families were reunited with their loved ones, prompting him to capture the scene with his camera. The resulting photograph resonated deeply with the American public, who were eager for images that symbolized hope and healing after a bitter and divisive war.

Yet for Stirm, the photograph was a reminder of loss rather than joy. While the nation saw a triumphant return, he saw a marriage that had crumbled in his absence. His divorce from Loretta was bitter, with legal battles over his military pension further adding to the difficulties of his reintegration into civilian life. Though he would go on to remarry and continue his service in the Air Force, the experience of betrayal and loss lingered.

Burst of Joy became a defining image of the Vietnam War’s aftermath, but it also serves as a metaphor for the war itself. Much like the conflict, what Americans were told about returning home did not always align with reality. The war had been sold as a noble effort, yet it ended in political strife, personal tragedy, and unresolved wounds. For every POW who returned home to a joyful embrace, there were families who never received such a moment. Thousands of American soldiers remained unaccounted for, classified as missing in action, leaving their loved ones to wonder about their fates for decades.

In reflecting on this moment, it is crucial to remember that history is often more complex than the images that define it. Burst of Joy remains an enduring symbol of resilience and reunion, but beneath the surface lies a story of heartbreak, of war’s lasting scars, and of the reality that not all homecomings are what they seem. Stirm’s story, like that of so many who served in Vietnam, is one of sacrifice—both on the battlefield and beyond. The war may have ended, but its consequences rippled through the lives of those who fought it long after the last troops returned home.